comredix.

Review · Fashion & style

Johnston & Murphy review

American dress shoe brand selling Goodyear-welted and cemented dress shoes in many widths, from about $100 on sale.

By the Comredix review desk · Updated November 21, 2026

Quality (40%)
7.8
Experience (25%)
8.8
Value (35%)
8.8

Johnston & Murphy is the easiest brand here to buy from if your feet are hard to fit. The Melton Cap Toe costs $199 and comes in sizes 6 to 16 and five widths from B to 3E, a range none of the English makers on this list match on a single model. J&M says the Melton uses Goodyear welt construction, so it can be resoled, and pairs it with a leather sole, a combination stacked leather and rubber heel, a leather lining with a perforated forefoot and its Optima Comfort System cushioning. That cushioning is the reason some buyers will prefer it over a traditional English shoe. J&M Insider members get free shipping and free returns. Shoppers should read each product page: the dress shoe section had 113 styles when we checked, many on Black Friday sale from $99.99, and not all of them are described as welted. For American full-grain leather, the Heritage Collection Dearborn Cap Toe is $298.

Who it is for

men who need a welted dress shoe in a wide or hard-to-find size

Price

Melton Cap Toe $199; Heritage Collection Dearborn Cap Toe $298.

Melton Cap Toe 5 out of 5 Customer Rating $199.00
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 21, 2026.

Key features

  • Melton Cap Toe uses Goodyear welt construction and a leather sole
  • Optima Comfort System with multi-layered cushioning
  • Leather lining with a perforated forefoot
  • Sizes 6 to 16 in B, C, D, E and 3E widths
  • Combination stacked leather and rubber heel

Strengths and weaknesses

  • Strength: Widest size and width range on this list, from 6 to 16 and B to 3E
  • Strength: Free shipping and free returns for J&M Insider members
  • Strength: Heritage Collection adds American full-grain leather styles at $298
  • Weakness: The product page does not say where the Melton is made
  • Weakness: Many cheaper J&M dress shoes on sale are not described as Goodyear welted, so check each page
  • Weakness: No factory resoling price is published on the product page

Key facts

  • Shoe priced: Melton Cap Toe, $199
  • Construction: Goodyear welt
  • Sizes: 6 to 16
  • Widths: B, C, D, E, 3E
  • Sole: Leather, stacked leather and rubber heel

Where it ranks

Johnston & Murphy is No. 3 in our Best Men's Dress Shoes verdict.

Alternatives we scored

Visit johnstonmurphy.com · Questions or corrections: editorial@comredix.com