Review · Fashion & style
Crockett & Jones review
Northampton maker of Goodyear-welted English shoes since 1879, with a Hand Grade line and its own factory repair service.
By the Comredix review desk · Updated November 21, 2026
- Quality (40%)
- 9.6
- Experience (25%)
- 8.6
- Value (35%)
- 7.6
Crockett & Jones is the strongest answer on this list to the question of who makes the best quality dress shoe. The Audley is a straight-cap Oxford from the Hand Grade Collection, built on the 337 last in an E (standard) fitting with a bark tanned single leather sole, and it costs $1,100 on the brand's US store. The company has made Goodyear welted shoes in Northampton, England since 1879 and says each pair takes up to eight weeks and more than 200 operations. Its repair page is unusually specific: the shoe goes back to the Northampton factory, is stripped to the upper and insole, re-welted on the original last and resoled, with prices from $250 for a single leather or rubber sole to $270 for hand grade soles. Crockett & Jones says a well kept pair can usually be repaired 3 or 4 times. The trade-offs are price and logistics: shoe trees are extra and repairs mean shipping to England. We compared documented features and published prices; we did not wear-test the shoes.
Who it is for
men who want the best-made classic Oxford and plan to resole it
Price
Hand Grade Audley cap-toe Oxford $1,100; factory resole from $250.
Audley Black Calf $1,100 Audley, a straight-cap Oxford, is one of our best selling original classics.
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 21, 2026.
Key features
- Audley is a straight-cap Oxford in black calf from the Hand Grade Collection
- Bark tanned single leather sole on the 337 last, E (standard) fitting
- Crockett & Jones says each pair takes up to eight weeks and over 200 operations to make
- Factory repair: single leather or rubber resole $250, hand grade single leather sole $270
- US store lists sizes 5 to 13 in USD
Strengths and weaknesses
- Strength: Goodyear welted in Northampton, England, where the company has made shoes since 1879
- Strength: Factory resoles re-welt the shoe on its original last
- Strength: The brand says it can usually repair a pair 3 or 4 times if well cared for
- Weakness: $1,100 for the Audley is more than five times the price of the Johnston & Murphy Melton
- Weakness: Shoe trees are not included
- Weakness: Factory repairs cost $250 to $270 and mean shipping the shoes back to Northampton
Key facts
- Shoe priced: Audley Black Calf, $1,100
- Construction: Goodyear welted
- Made in: Northampton, England
- Sole: Single leather, bark tanned
- Factory resole: From $250
Where it ranks
Crockett & Jones is No. 1 in our Best Men's Dress Shoes verdict.
Alternatives we scored
- Meermin8.6
- Johnston & Murphy8.4
- Loake8.4
- Beckett Simonon8.3
Visit crockettandjones.com · Questions or corrections: editorial@comredix.com