Review · Fashion & style
Beckett Simonon review
Made-to-order dress shoe brand that builds Blake-stitched shoes in Bogotá, Colombia from Italian calfskin.
By the Comredix review desk · Updated November 21, 2026
- Quality (40%)
- 7.6
- Experience (25%)
- 8.4
- Value (35%)
- 8.9
Beckett Simonon sells its shoes made to order, which it says lets it focus on materials while keeping prices lower. The Dean Oxford costs $249, and during Black Friday the brand offered any two men's pairs for $359. Construction is Blake stitching: the outsole is stitched to the insole and upper rather than glued, which Beckett Simonon says makes the shoe sturdy and easy to resole, and the waist is tapered. Soles, midsoles and heel stacks are vegetable tanned leather, and the full-grain calfskin comes from Grupo Mastrotto in Arzignano, Italy. Every product is made in Bogotá, Colombia. Blake shoes are usually sleeker and more flexible than Goodyear welted ones, but they lack the welt that lets a cobbler rebuild the sole the traditional way, so we score build quality below Meermin. Unworn pairs can be returned or exchanged free within 30 days in the contiguous US.
Who it is for
men who will wait for a made-to-order shoe to save money
Price
Dean Oxford $249; Black Friday offer of two men's pairs for $359.
Best Seller Dean oxfords full-grain leather $249
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 21, 2026.
Key features
- Blake stitched soles, with the outsole stitched to the insole and upper rather than glued
- Full-grain calfskin from Grupo Mastrotto in Arzignano, Italy
- Midsoles, outsoles and heel stacks in vegetable tanned leather
- Every pair is made to order in Bogotá, Colombia
- Free returns and exchanges of unworn items within 30 days in the contiguous US
Strengths and weaknesses
- Strength: Black Friday offer of two men's pairs for $359 when we checked
- Strength: Blake construction is described by the brand as easy to resole
- Strength: Order updates with photos and videos while your pair is made
- Weakness: Made to order, so you wait for production instead of getting stock shoes
- Weakness: Blake stitching is not a welt; a cobbler cannot re-welt it like a Goodyear shoe
- Weakness: Returns must be unworn and are free only within the contiguous US
Key facts
- Shoe priced: Dean Oxford, $249
- Construction: Blake stitched
- Leather: Grupo Mastrotto calfskin, Italy
- Made in: Bogotá, Colombia
- Returns: 30 days, unworn, contiguous US
Where it ranks
Beckett Simonon is No. 5 in our Best Men's Dress Shoes verdict.
Alternatives we scored
- Crockett & Jones8.7
- Meermin8.6
- Johnston & Murphy8.4
- Loake8.4
Visit beckettsimonon.com · Questions or corrections: editorial@comredix.com