IPSY Extra review

IPSY Extra is the plan that took over from BoxyCharm: the ipsy.com/boxycharm address now opens the IPSY Extra page, which promises 5 full-size products every month for $32 plus shipping. IPSY's shop listing says a box holds up to $200 worth of beauty, picked to match your answers in the Beauty Quiz. The plan page shows the whole monthly collection before you join, and the November lineup included Rare Beauty Stay Vulnerable Melting Blush, Laura Mercier Real Flawless concealer, Glow Recipe Watermelon Glow Hue Drops, Drybar Big Brew root spray and Summer Fridays Blush Butter Balm. Members receive 5 products from that collection, so you will not get every item pictured. Shipping is extra, which narrows the gap with Allure Beauty Box, whose $30 price includes shipping in the contiguous US. For buyers who want full sizes from brands they already know, the published lineup and the $32 price make it the strongest monthly value we compared.

Who it is for

former BoxyCharm members who want full sizes every month

Price

$32 per month plus shipping.

Get IPSY Extra and receive 5 full-size products every month for just $32.
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 13, 2026.

Key features

• 5 full-size products every month
• IPSY says each box holds up to $200 worth of beauty
• Products personalized from the IPSY Beauty Quiz
• November lineup included Rare Beauty, Laura Mercier, Glow Recipe, Drybar and Summer Fridays
• Members can shop the IPSY Shop for add-ons such as Mystery Bags from $16

Strengths and weaknesses

• Strength: Full-size products only, unlike sample boxes
• Strength: The ipsy.com/boxycharm address opens the IPSY Extra page, so BoxyCharm fans land in the same plan
• Strength: Monthly lineup is published on the plan page before you join
• Weakness: Shipping is charged on top of the $32 price
• Weakness: You receive 5 products from a published collection, not every item shown
• Weakness: Costs more than twice IPSY Original, which is $15 for samples

Key facts

• Price: $32 per month plus shipping
• Products per box: 5 full-size
• Stated value: Up to $200
• Frequency: Monthly
• Formerly: BoxyCharm (ipsy.com/boxycharm)

Where it ranks

IPSY Extra is No. 1 in our Best Beauty Subscription Boxes verdict.