comredix.
Beauty & fragrance · Ranking

9 Best Beauty Subscription Boxes of 2026

By the Comredix review desk · Updated November 13, 2026 · Next review December 28, 2026 · 9 products compared

Ranked firstIPSY Extraformer BoxyCharm members who want full sizes every month8.9

The short version

Start with IPSY Extra if you want full-size products from brands you know: 5 full sizes a month for $32, with the monthly lineup published before you join. Allure Beauty Box is the pick if you want shipping included, with six editor picks for $30, and IPSY Original is the budget choice at $15 for 5 deluxe samples. FabFitFun lets you choose all 6 full-size products each season, Birchbox lets you customize every monthly box from $22, Petit Vour sticks to vegan and cruelty-free beauty from $25, and Beauty Heroes sends full-size clean products from one brand a month. GLOSSYBOX suits UK shoppers, and Scentbird covers fragrance with one 8 mL vial a month.

Short answer

IPSY Extra is the best beauty subscription box for shoppers who want full-size products in 2026: it sends 5 full-size items a month for $32 plus shipping, with a stated value of up to $200. Allure Beauty Box suits subscribers who want shipping included, with six editor picks for $30 a box. IPSY Original is the cheapest at $15 a month for 5 deluxe samples, as of November 2026.

This list is for beauty fans comparing monthly and seasonal boxes on what they cost, what they hold and which brands show up. We compared documented box contents, stated values, plan terms and published prices for 9 subscriptions sold today; we did not test the boxes by hand. Scores weigh quality at 40%, experience at 25% and value at 35%. Quality covers the number and size of products and the brands in recent boxes; experience covers choice, shipping and commitment; value compares the price with the box's stated value and what you actually receive. Stated values are the vendors' own figures. Facts and prices come from each vendor's own pages as shown on November 13, 2026. GLOSSYBOX and Scentbird showed only pound sterling prices from our location, so their USD prices are pending. BoxyCharm now lives on as IPSY Extra, since ipsy.com/boxycharm opens that plan. We left out Cocotique because its site now publishes health content and no longer sells a box, and LOOKFANTASTIC because its subscription pages did not load for us.

Figures worth knowing

The ranking at a glance

  1. 1IPSY Extraformer BoxyCharm members who want full sizes every month8.9
  2. 2Allure Beauty Boxsubscribers who want editor picks with shipping included8.8
  3. 3IPSY Originalbudget shoppers who want to sample new brands8.5
  4. 4FabFitFunshoppers who want beauty mixed with home and fashion every season8.4
  5. 5Birchboxbeauty fans who want to pick each product8.3
  6. 6Petit Vourvegan and cruelty-free shoppers8.1
  7. 7Beauty Heroesclean skincare buyers who want full-size products8.0
  8. 8GLOSSYBOXUK shoppers who want a low-cost monthly box7.7
  9. 9Scentbirdfragrance fans who want a new scent each month7.7

How we make the call

Every entry gets a 0 to 10 rating on the three criteria below, and the order follows the weighted total. The ratings rest on the documented features and published prices on each maker's own pages, never hands-on testing.

  • 40%Quality
  • 25%Experience
  • 35%Value

See the full method

  1. No. 1, top ranked

    IPSY Extra

    IPSY's monthly box of 5 full-size beauty products, picked from a Beauty Quiz; the old BoxyCharm address now leads to this plan.

    8.9of 10

    Best for former BoxyCharm members who want full sizes every month

    Quality
    9.0
    Experience
    8.6
    Value
    9.0

    Price

    $32 per month plus shipping

    Quoted from the IPSY Extra pricing page on November 13, 2026: Get IPSY Extra and receive 5 full-size products every month for just $32.

    IPSY Extra is the plan that took over from BoxyCharm: the ipsy.com/boxycharm address now opens the IPSY Extra page, which promises 5 full-size products every month for $32 plus shipping. IPSY's shop listing says a box holds up to $200 worth of beauty, picked to match your answers in the Beauty Quiz. The plan page shows the whole monthly collection before you join, and the November lineup included Rare Beauty Stay Vulnerable Melting Blush, Laura Mercier Real Flawless concealer, Glow Recipe Watermelon Glow Hue Drops, Drybar Big Brew root spray and Summer Fridays Blush Butter Balm. Members receive 5 products from that collection, so you will not get every item pictured. Shipping is extra, which narrows the gap with Allure Beauty Box, whose $30 price includes shipping in the contiguous US. For buyers who want full sizes from brands they already know, the published lineup and the $32 price make it the strongest monthly value we compared.

    What it does well

    • +Full-size products only, unlike sample boxes
    • +The ipsy.com/boxycharm address opens the IPSY Extra page, so BoxyCharm fans land in the same plan
    • +Monthly lineup is published on the plan page before you join

    Where it falls short

    • −Shipping is charged on top of the $32 price
    • −You receive 5 products from a published collection, not every item shown
    • −Costs more than twice IPSY Original, which is $15 for samples
    Price
    $32 per month plus shipping
    Products per box
    5 full-size
    Stated value
    Up to $200
    Frequency
    Monthly
    Formerly
    BoxyCharm (ipsy.com/boxycharm)

    Visit ipsy.com|Read the full IPSY Extra profile

  2. No. 2

    Allure Beauty Box

    A monthly box of six products picked by Allure editors, run under license from Conde Nast.

    8.8of 10

    Best for subscribers who want editor picks with shipping included

    Quality
    8.8
    Experience
    8.8
    Value
    8.8

    Price

    $30 per box, free shipping in the contiguous US

    Quoted from the Allure Beauty Box pricing page on November 13, 2026: Subscribe & Save $ 30 / box Never miss a box

    Allure Beauty Box sends six products picked by Allure editors each month for $30 a box, and the price includes shipping in the contiguous US, which IPSY charges separately. The box page states that each curation is valued at $125 or more, and new members get a free gift in the first box. The November box listed a Nulastin brow serum as the new member gift alongside a choice of Drunk Elephant product. Members also get early access to limited editions and a members-only store with discounts of up to 50%. If you are unsure, the Beauty Discovery Box costs $50 once with no renewal, which is a useful trial. The trade-off is control: the editors choose the products, and the box mixes sizes rather than promising full sizes like IPSY Extra. The brand is licensed from Conde Nast to MarZ Licensing, LLC, according to the site footer.

    What it does well

    • +Shipping is included in the $30 price for the contiguous US
    • +A free gift arrives with the first box
    • +You can try one box for $50 without a subscription

    Where it falls short

    • −Free shipping covers only the contiguous US
    • −Products are editor picks, so you do not choose each item
    • −Box contents mix full sizes and smaller sizes
    Price
    $30 per box
    Products per box
    6
    Stated value
    $125 or more
    Shipping
    Free in the contiguous US
    One-time box
    $50

    Visit allure.com|Read the full Allure Beauty Box profile

  3. No. 3

    IPSY Original

    IPSY's entry plan, formerly the Glam Bag, with 5 deluxe-size samples a month.

    8.5of 10

    Best for budget shoppers who want to sample new brands

    Quality
    7.8
    Experience
    8.6
    Value
    9.2

    Price

    $15 per month plus shipping

    Quoted from the IPSY Original pricing page on November 13, 2026: Get IPSY Original and receive 5 deluxe samples every month for just $15.

    IPSY Original is the plan that used to be called the Glam Bag, and the ipsy.com/glambag address now opens it. For $15 a month plus shipping you get 5 deluxe-size samples, which IPSY's shop listing values at up to $70, matched to your Beauty Quiz answers. The November collection included Benefit The POREfessional Concealer, Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer, Smashbox Photo Finish primer and a Briogeo hair mask, so the brands are recognizable even when the sizes are small. That makes it the cheapest verified box on this list and a sensible way to test a foundation or a mascara before paying for a full tube. The limits are the sizes and the value ceiling: samples run out fast, and the stated value is well below the $125 or more that Allure quotes. If you find you keep buying the full sizes anyway, IPSY Extra at $32 is the natural step up.

    What it does well

    • +Cheapest verified monthly price on this list at $15
    • +Lets you try brands before buying full sizes
    • +Upgrade path to IPSY Extra and IPSY Ultimate

    Where it falls short

    • −Deluxe samples, not full-size products
    • −Shipping is charged on top of the $15
    • −Stated value of up to $70 is the lowest of the monthly boxes here
    Price
    $15 per month plus shipping
    Products per box
    5 deluxe samples
    Stated value
    Up to $70
    Frequency
    Monthly
    Formerly
    Glam Bag (ipsy.com/glambag)

    Visit ipsy.com|Read the full IPSY Original profile

  4. No. 4

    FabFitFun

    A seasonal box of 6 full-size beauty, home, fashion and wellness products, plus weekly member sales.

    8.4of 10

    Best for shoppers who want beauty mixed with home and fashion every season

    Quality
    8.6
    Experience
    7.6
    Value
    8.8

    Price

    $64.99 per box on the annual plan ($259.96 a year); $79.99 per box billed quarterly

    Quoted from the FabFitFun pricing page on November 13, 2026: Annual $64.99 /box Best Value

    FabFitFun is a seasonal box rather than a monthly one: every 3 months you choose 6 full-size products from more than 100 options, and FabFitFun puts the average box value at $350. The annual plan works out to $64.99 a box but is billed as $259.96 a year, while the flexible seasonal plan costs $79.99 a box billed quarterly. Beauty is only part of the mix. The Winter 2026 box listed Rare Beauty eyeshadow sticks, a Laneige tinted lip serum, Dr. Jart eye cream and Briogeo shampoo next to a Caraway pan, a throw and a robe. Members also get weekly sales with discounts of up to 70% and can swap box products for store credit. FabFitFun says it has over 1 million members. Choose it if you like picking every item and want home and fashion in the same box; choose a monthly beauty box if you only want makeup and skincare.

    What it does well

    • +You pick every product in the box
    • +Mixes beauty brands such as Rare Beauty, Laneige and Dr. Jart with home goods
    • +Price Match Guarantee if you find a product cheaper elsewhere, subject to terms

    Where it falls short

    • −Ships every 3 months, not monthly
    • −Annual plan is billed $259.96 up front
    • −Not beauty only, so fewer beauty items per box than a pure beauty box
    Annual plan
    $64.99 per box, billed $259.96 a year
    Seasonal plan
    $79.99 per box, billed quarterly
    Products per box
    6 full-size
    Frequency
    Every 3 months
    Members
    Over 1 million, according to FabFitFun

    Visit fabfitfun.com|Read the full FabFitFun profile

  5. No. 5

    Birchbox

    A customizable beauty box where you choose samples, travel sizes and full sizes, monthly or every other month.

    8.3of 10

    Best for beauty fans who want to pick each product

    Quality
    8.0
    Experience
    8.6
    Value
    8.4

    Price

    From $22 per box for Birchbox Monthly; Birchbox Signature from $44 per box every other month

    Quoted from the Birchbox pricing page on November 13, 2026: Starting At $22 /Per Box

    Birchbox is built around choice. Its plan page offers two boxes: Birchbox Monthly, from $22 a box, with 6 products including 1 full size and up to a $75 value, and Birchbox Signature, from $44 a box every other month, with 4 full-size products and up to a $175 value. Both can be customized every time, and the homepage says you can choose from samples, travel-size and full-size options, or let Birchbox build the box from your beauty goals quiz. That level of control is the main reason to pick it over IPSY, where the products are matched for you. The Members Market lets you buy full sizes of past favorites. The drawbacks are size and cadence: the Monthly box is mostly samples, Signature ships only every other month, and the plan page does not show shipping costs, so check checkout before comparing it with Allure's free shipping.

    What it does well

    • +You choose every product, or let Birchbox build the box
    • +Two plans: monthly sampling or a bi-monthly full-size box
    • +Beauty goals quiz to start

    Where it falls short

    • −Only 1 of 6 Monthly products is full size
    • −Signature ships every other month, not monthly
    • −Shipping cost is not shown on the plan page
    Monthly plan
    From $22 per box, 6 products
    Signature plan
    From $44 per box, 4 full-size
    Monthly value
    Up to $75
    Signature value
    Up to $175
    Customization
    Every box

    Visit birchbox.com|Read the full Birchbox profile

  6. No. 6

    Petit Vour

    A monthly box of cruelty-free, vegan and non-toxic beauty products curated to a beauty profile.

    8.1of 10

    Best for vegan and cruelty-free shoppers

    Quality
    8.0
    Experience
    8.0
    Value
    8.4

    Price

    From $25 per box; Petit Vour Plus from $28 with free shipping

    Quoted from the Petit Vour pricing page on November 13, 2026: Starting at $25/Box

    Petit Vour limits its box to products that are cruelty-free, non-toxic and plant-based, which no other box on this list promises. The Vegan Beauty Box starts at $25 a box and sends 3 to 4 products a month with a stated total value of $75 to $100, mixing makeup, hair care, body care and skincare matched to the profile you fill in at sign-up. Rating the month's items earns 400 PV Points, worth $4, to spend in the Petit Vour store. The step-up Petit Vour Plus box holds 3 to 5 travel and full-size products, values them at over $100 and costs from $28 with free shipping. Boxes ship in batches between the 10th and 20th of each month, and monthly plans can be canceled from your account or by email. The trade-off for the strict standard is volume: 3 to 4 items is fewer than the 5 or 6 from IPSY and Allure.

    What it does well

    • +The only box here limited to vegan, cruelty-free products
    • +$4 store credit a month for reviewing the box
    • +Monthly plans can be canceled from your login

    Where it falls short

    • −Fewer items per box than IPSY or Allure
    • −Boxes ship in batches between the 10th and 20th, so timing varies
    • −Free shipping is stated for Petit Vour Plus, not for the standard box
    Price
    From $25 per box
    Products per box
    3 to 4
    Stated value
    $75 to $100
    Standard
    Cruelty-free, vegan, non-toxic
    Review credit
    $4 a month (400 PV Points)

    Visit petitvour.com|Read the full Petit Vour profile

  7. No. 7

    Beauty Heroes

    A clean beauty subscription built around one featured brand each month, with a full-size Hero product and a Sidekick.

    8.0of 10

    Best for clean skincare buyers who want full-size products

    Quality
    8.4
    Experience
    8.0
    Value
    7.4

    Price

    From $41.95 per month on a 12-month plan ($503.40); $48.95 per month on 3 months; one-time box $62.95

    Quoted from the Beauty Heroes pricing page on November 13, 2026: 12 Month $503.40 ($41.95/month)

    Beauty Heroes takes a different approach from the sample boxes. Each month it features one clean beauty brand and sends a full-size Hero product with a Sidekick. The November Discovery came from RMS Beauty, with a 180 ml Kakadu Body Butter listed at $49 and a 100 ml Kakadu Beauty Body Oil at $52, for a stated box value of $127. Plans are prepaid: 3 months costs $146.85 ($48.95 a month), 6 months $269.70 ($44.95 a month) and 12 months $503.40 ($41.95 a month), and a one-time box costs $62.95. Members get 15% off every purchase in the Beauty Heroes store, which stocks brands such as OSEA, Ursa Major and True Botanicals, and store orders over $75 ship free in the US. It is the priciest box here and the least varied, since one brand fills each box, but it suits buyers who prefer two full-size products to five samples.

    What it does well

    • +Full-size skincare and body care from a single brand each month
    • +15% member discount across the Beauty Heroes store
    • +Free US shipping on store orders over $75

    Where it falls short

    • −Most expensive monthly price on this list
    • −Plans are prepaid for 3, 6 or 12 months
    • −One brand per month means less variety than IPSY or Allure
    12-month plan
    $503.40 ($41.95 per month)
    3-month plan
    $146.85 ($48.95 per month)
    One-time box
    $62.95
    November value
    $127 (RMS Beauty)
    Member discount
    15% off every purchase

    Visit beautyheroes.com|Read the full Beauty Heroes profile

  8. No. 8

    GLOSSYBOX

    A UK beauty subscription that sends 5 products to try each month, sold in pounds sterling.

    7.7of 10

    Best for UK shoppers who want a low-cost monthly box

    Quality
    7.6
    Experience
    7.6
    Value
    8.0

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    No US price was listed when we checked. See the GLOSSYBOX pricing page.

    GLOSSYBOX is a UK beauty subscription that sends 5 beauty products to try each month, with free delivery on all subscriptions. Its plan page offers a flexible monthly plan and prepaid bundles of 3, 6 and 12 boxes, and the price per box falls as the prepaid term gets longer. Subscribers earn Glossy Credit to spend on the site and get discounts on limited edition boxes such as themed edits and an advent calendar. From our location the site showed prices only in pounds sterling, so we could not verify a USD price, and the pages we checked did not confirm delivery to the US. That is why it sits below the US boxes on this list despite a low price per box. It suits UK readers comparing it with IPSY and Allure, but US shoppers should check delivery before signing up.

    What it does well

    • +Prepaid plans lower the price per box
    • +Delivery is free on all subscriptions
    • +Subscribers get discounts on limited edition boxes

    Where it falls short

    • −Showed only pound sterling prices from our location, so the USD check is pending
    • −We could not confirm US delivery on the pages we checked
    • −Fewer choices over products than Birchbox or FabFitFun
    Products per box
    5
    Delivery
    Free on all subscriptions
    Plans
    Monthly, 3, 6 and 12 boxes
    Currency shown
    Pounds sterling
    Rewards
    Glossy Credit

    Visit glossybox.com|Read the full GLOSSYBOX profile

  9. No. 9

    Scentbird

    A fragrance subscription that sends one 8 mL vial of a designer scent each month from a queue you build.

    7.7of 10

    Best for fragrance fans who want a new scent each month

    Quality
    7.4
    Experience
    8.2
    Value
    7.6

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    No US price was listed when we checked. See the Scentbird pricing page.

    Scentbird is the fragrance option on this list. Instead of a mixed box, it sends one 8 mL vial a month of a designer scent you choose from more than 600, which Scentbird says is about 120 sprays and enough for daily wear for a month. You start with a fragrance quiz, build a monthly queue of scents and can skip or cancel at any time, and shipping is free in the US. The first subscription comes with a free case for the vial. It suits people who want to try perfumes and colognes before paying for a full bottle, and it gives more control than any beauty box because you name the exact product. The limits are scope and price checking: it covers fragrance only, sends one item a month, and from our location the site showed only pound sterling prices, so the USD price is pending.

    What it does well

    • +You pick the exact scent each month
    • +An 8 mL vial lasts about a month of daily wear
    • +Free US shipping

    Where it falls short

    • −Showed only pound sterling prices from our location, so the USD check is pending
    • −Fragrance only, no makeup or skincare
    • −One product a month, compared with 5 or 6 in beauty boxes
    Catalog
    600+ designer scents
    Monthly size
    8 mL vial, about 120 sprays
    Shipping
    Free in the US
    Commitment
    Skip or cancel anytime
    Bonus
    Free case with first subscription

    Visit scentbird.com|Read the full Scentbird profile

Before you pick a product or a plan

Decide between samples and full sizes

Sample boxes cost less but run out fast. IPSY Original sends 5 deluxe samples for $15, while IPSY Extra sends 5 full sizes for $32 and Beauty Heroes builds each box around full-size products. Birchbox Monthly includes 1 full size among 6 products.

Treat stated value as a ceiling

Every vendor quotes a box value: up to $70 for IPSY Original, $125 or more for Allure, up to $200 for IPSY Extra and an average of $350 for FabFitFun. These are retail prices of the items, not what you would have spent, so compare them with the products you would actually use.

Add shipping before you compare

IPSY charges shipping on top of its $15 and $32 plans. Allure Beauty Box includes shipping in the contiguous US, Petit Vour Plus ships free, and GLOSSYBOX delivers free on all subscriptions. A few dollars of shipping changes the ranking on cheap boxes.

Choose how much control you want

FabFitFun and Birchbox let you pick every product. IPSY matches products to a Beauty Quiz, Allure editors pick the box, and Scentbird lets you queue the exact scent. If you have sensitive skin or strict ingredient rules, pick a box that lets you choose.

Check the commitment

IPSY, Allure, Birchbox and Petit Vour run monthly. FabFitFun ships every 3 months and its annual plan bills $259.96 up front, and Beauty Heroes plans are prepaid for 3, 6 or 12 months. Try a one-time box first where offered: Allure sells one for $50 and Beauty Heroes for $62.95.

Questions readers ask

What is the best beauty subscription box?
IPSY Extra is the best beauty subscription box for most people in 2026. It sends 5 full-size products a month for $32 plus shipping, with a stated value of up to $200. Allure Beauty Box is the closest alternative at $30 a box with free shipping in the contiguous US.
What is the cheapest beauty subscription box?
IPSY Original is the cheapest verified box on this list at $15 a month plus shipping. It sends 5 deluxe-size samples that IPSY values at up to $70. Birchbox Monthly is next, from $22 a box for 6 products.
Does BoxyCharm still exist?
BoxyCharm now runs as IPSY Extra. The ipsy.com/boxycharm address opens the IPSY Extra page, which offers 5 full-size products every month for $32 plus shipping.
Which beauty box lets you choose your products?
Birchbox and FabFitFun let you choose every product. Birchbox lets you customize every box from $22 a month, and FabFitFun members pick all 6 full-size products from 100+ options each season.
Is Allure Beauty Box worth it?
Yes, if you want editor picks with shipping included. It costs $30 a box for six products that Allure values at $125 or more, and shipping is free in the contiguous US. You can try a single Beauty Discovery Box for $50 with no renewal.
Is there a vegan beauty subscription box?
Yes, Petit Vour sells only cruelty-free, non-toxic and plant-based products. Its box starts at $25 for 3 to 4 products with a stated value of $75 to $100, and rating the box earns $4 in store credit each month.
How often does FabFitFun ship?
FabFitFun ships every 3 months. Each seasonal box holds 6 full-size products, costing $64.99 a box on the annual plan ($259.96 a year) or $79.99 a box billed quarterly.

Spotted an error or a price change? Write to editorial@comredix.com

How we work is in our editorial policy. Makers change prices, plans and terms often, so check the price on their site before you buy or upgrade.

More rankings