comredix.

Review · Fashion & style

Church's review

English luxury shoemaker, part of the Prada Group, whose Consul Oxford has been in the range since 1945.

By the Comredix review desk · Updated November 21, 2026

Quality (40%)
9.2
Experience (25%)
7.2
Value (35%)
6.5

Church's is the luxury English name on this list. The Consul R 2.0 is a cap-toe Oxford, a style Church's says it first introduced in 1945, here in grain calfskin with a fumé polished finish. The product page lists Goodyear 2.0 construction, a leather sole, leather lining and insole, blind eyelets and cotton laces, and says it is made in England. Church's also runs a repair service it calls The Art of Repair, covering care, maintenance and restoration. The problem is value: at $1,320 the Consul costs $220 more than the Crockett & Jones Audley, and the Prince 2 polished calfskin Oxford is $1,890. When we checked, the Consul was on pre-order and sold out online. We score quality high on the documented construction and English manufacture, and value lowest on the list because the documented specs do not exceed cheaper English makers here.

Who it is for

men who want a luxury English Oxford with a recognizable name

Price

Consul R 2.0 Oxford $1,320; Prince 2 Polished Calfskin Oxford $1,890.

Consul R 2.0 Fumé Grain Calfskin Oxford $ 1,320
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 21, 2026.

Key features

  • Consul is a classic cap-toe Oxford first introduced in 1945
  • Grain calfskin upper with a fumé polished finish
  • Goodyear 2.0 construction with a leather sole
  • Leather lining and insole, blind eyelets
  • Made in England

Strengths and weaknesses

  • Strength: Made in England with Goodyear construction
  • Strength: The Art of Repair service covers care, maintenance and restoration
  • Strength: US store with phone ordering seven days a week
  • Weakness: Most expensive shoe on this list at $1,320, with the Prince 2 at $1,890
  • Weakness: The Consul R 2.0 we checked was on pre-order and sold out online
  • Weakness: No repair prices published on the product page

Key facts

  • Shoe priced: Consul R 2.0, $1,320
  • Construction: Goodyear 2.0
  • Made in: England
  • Upper: Grain calfskin, fumé polished
  • Availability: Pre-order when checked

Where it ranks

Church's is No. 8 in our Best Men's Dress Shoes verdict.

Alternatives we scored

Visit church-footwear.com · Questions or corrections: editorial@comredix.com