comredix.
Shopping & services · Ranking

10 Best Subscription Boxes of 2026

By the Comredix review desk · Updated November 13, 2026 · Next review December 28, 2026 · 10 products compared

Ranked firstIPSYbeauty shoppers who want the lowest monthly price8.8

The short version

Start with IPSY if you want something new every month at the lowest price: IPSY Original sends 5 beauty products for $15 a month, and IPSY Extra sends 5 full-size products for $32. Universal Yums is the best food box at $19 with free US shipping, FabFitFun gives the most choice with 6 full-size products per $64.99 seasonal box, and BarkBox is the pet pick from $24 a month. Stitch Fix suits people who want clothes picked for them for a $20 styling fee, Book of the Month suits fiction readers, Birchbox offers customizable beauty boxes from $22, Bokksu is the Japanese snack box from $32.99 a month, Alltrue (formerly Causebox) focuses on ethical brands at $84.95 a season, and Loot Crate covers pop culture collectibles.

Short answer

IPSY is the best subscription box for most shoppers in 2026; IPSY Original sends 5 beauty products every month for $15 plus shipping. Universal Yums suits snack lovers and families at $19 a box with free US shipping, and FabFitFun suits shoppers who want 6 full-size products they choose themselves at $64.99 a seasonal box, as of November 2026. Dog owners should pick BarkBox from $24 a month, and people who want clothes should try Stitch Fix for a $20 styling fee.

This list is for shoppers choosing a monthly or seasonal subscription box, whether for themselves, a pet or a gift. We compared documented box contents, plan options and published prices for 10 boxes sold in the US today; we did not order the boxes ourselves. Scores weigh quality at 40%, experience at 25% and value at 35%. Quality covers what each box contains, product sizes and how much choice members get; experience covers customization, skipping, shipping and how clear the plans are; value compares the starting price with what each box includes. Starting prices are each vendor's lowest published plan price, and some require a longer commitment. Facts and prices come from each vendor's own pages as shown on November 13, 2026. Loot Crate showed prices in a non-US currency from our location, so its USD price is pending. HelloFresh and other meal kits are covered in our separate meal kit list.

Figures worth knowing

The ranking at a glance

  1. 1IPSYbeauty shoppers who want the lowest monthly price8.8
  2. 2FabFitFunshoppers who want full-size beauty and home products8.7
  3. 3Universal Yumssnack fans and families who want a monthly food box8.7
  4. 4BarkBoxdog owners who want new toys and treats each month8.6
  5. 5Birchboxbeauty shoppers who want to customize every box8.3
  6. 6Book of the Monthfiction readers who want one new book a month8.3
  7. 7Stitch Fixpeople who want clothes picked for them8.3
  8. 8Bokksufans of Japanese snacks and tea8.2
  9. 9Alltrueshoppers who want sustainable products8.1
  10. 10Loot Cratepop culture and collectibles fans7.5

How we make the call

Every entry gets a 0 to 10 rating on the three criteria below, and the order follows the weighted total. The ratings rest on the documented features and published prices on each maker's own pages, never hands-on testing.

  • 40%Quality
  • 25%Experience
  • 35%Value

See the full method

  1. No. 1, top ranked

    IPSY

    A monthly beauty subscription that sends 5 personalized makeup, skincare and hair products, with Original, Extra and Ultimate tiers.

    8.8of 10

    Best for beauty shoppers who want the lowest monthly price

    Quality
    8.4
    Experience
    9.0
    Value
    9.2

    Price

    IPSY Original from $15 a month plus shipping; IPSY Extra $32 a month

    Quoted from the IPSY pricing page on November 13, 2026: Get IPSY Original and receive 5 deluxe samples every month for just $15.

    IPSY is the cheapest way to get a box every month. Its Original tier costs $15 a month plus shipping and sends 5 deluxe beauty samples, and IPSY Extra sends 5 full-size products every month for $32. A third tier, Ultimate, sits above both. Each month IPSY publishes the lineup members picked from; the November collection included Benefit Cosmetics, Anastasia Beverly Hills, Briogeo, Smashbox and Innisfree. That makes it easy to judge what a box contains before you join. The trade-off is scope: every IPSY tier is beauty only, and the $15 tier sends samples rather than full-size products, so shoppers who want home goods or full-size skincare will get more from FabFitFun or Birchbox Signature. For a shopper who wants a small, regular beauty delivery at the lowest monthly cost, IPSY gives the clearest price and the most products per dollar among the boxes we compared.

    What it does well

    • +Lowest monthly price on this list at $15
    • +Five products in every box at both main tiers
    • +Clear step up to full-size products at $32

    Where it falls short

    • −Shipping is charged on top of the $15 price
    • −Original tier sends deluxe samples, not full sizes
    • −Beauty only, so it does not suit shoppers after lifestyle or home items
    Starting price
    $15 a month plus shipping
    Products per box
    5
    Full-size tier
    IPSY Extra, $32 a month
    Frequency
    Monthly
    Category
    Beauty

    Visit ipsy.com|Read the full IPSY profile

  2. No. 2

    FabFitFun

    A seasonal membership box where members choose 6 full-size beauty, home and lifestyle products every three months.

    8.7of 10

    Best for shoppers who want full-size beauty and home products

    Quality
    8.8
    Experience
    8.2
    Value
    8.8

    Price

    Annual plan $64.99 per seasonal box; Seasonal plan $79.99 per box billed quarterly

    Quoted from the FabFitFun pricing page on November 13, 2026: Annual $64.99 /box Best Value

    FabFitFun is a seasonal box rather than a monthly one: members choose 6 full-size products every three months from a list of 100+ items. The Annual plan costs $64.99 a box and the more flexible Seasonal plan costs $79.99 a box, billed quarterly. The Winter 2026 box mixes beauty and home, with items listed on the site such as a Rare Beauty eyeshadow set, a Voluspa candle, a Caraway pan and Parachute Home towels. Membership also opens weekly drops and member prices of up to 70% off, and annual members can swap box products for credit. FabFitFun says it has over 1 million members. The trade-offs are timing and commitment: you get four boxes a year, and the lowest price requires an annual plan. For a shopper who would rather get fewer, bigger boxes of full-size products they picked themselves, it offers the widest product range on this list.

    What it does well

    • +Every product is full size and chosen by the member
    • +Mixes beauty with home goods, such as candles, towels and cookware
    • +Annual plan price drops to $64.99 a box

    Where it falls short

    • −Ships every 3 months, not monthly
    • −The cheapest price needs an annual commitment
    • −Seasonal plan costs $79.99 a box
    Starting price
    $64.99 a box on the Annual plan
    Frequency
    Every 3 months
    Products per box
    6 full-size, member choice
    Members
    Over 1 million, per the company
    Flexible plan
    Seasonal, $79.99 a box

    Visit fabfitfun.com|Read the full FabFitFun profile

  3. No. 3

    Universal Yums

    A monthly snack box built around one country each month, sold in three sizes with free US shipping.

    8.7of 10

    Best for snack fans and families who want a monthly food box

    Quality
    8.2
    Experience
    9.0
    Value
    9.0

    Price

    From $19 a box with free US shipping

    Quoted from the Universal Yums pricing page on November 13, 2026: Yum Box 5-7 Snacks $19/box Starting price

    Universal Yums sends a box of snacks from a different country each month, and its price includes free US shipping. The Yum Box holds 5 to 7 snacks from $19 a box with a 16-page booklet, the most popular Yum Yum Box holds 10 to 12 snacks from $27, and the Super Yum Box holds 15 to 18 snacks plus a specialty drink or food from $41. When we checked, the current box was Spain, with snacks such as fried egg-flavored potato chips and lemon cream sandwich cookies listed on the home page. The company says it has sold over 13 million boxes. Because shipping is already in the price, the $19 box is one of the cheapest true all-in costs on this list. The limits are that you cannot pick individual snacks and the smallest box is modest. For a household that wants one fun food delivery a month at a known price, it is a strong pick.

    What it does well

    • +Free US shipping is included in the price
    • +Three box sizes from $19 to $41
    • +Each month's country and snack list is shown on the site

    Where it falls short

    • −Food only, with no choice of individual snacks
    • −The $19 box holds 5 to 7 snacks
    • −Allergies are handled through a FAQ, not a custom box
    Starting price
    $19 a box
    Shipping
    Free in the US
    Box sizes
    5 to 7, 10 to 12 or 15 to 18 snacks
    Boxes sold
    Over 13 million, per the company
    Theme
    One country per box

    Visit universalyums.com|Read the full Universal Yums profile

  4. No. 4

    BarkBox

    A monthly dog box with plush toys and treats on a new theme each month, plus a Super Chewer option for tough chewers.

    8.6of 10

    Best for dog owners who want new toys and treats each month

    Quality
    8.6
    Experience
    8.8
    Value
    8.5

    Price

    From $24 a month with free shipping

    Quoted from the BarkBox pricing page on November 13, 2026: From $24/mo + free shipping

    BarkBox is the pet pick on this list. The Classic box sends 2 plush toys and 2 bags of healthy treats on a new theme each month, from $24 a month with free shipping, and BarkBox was adding a free extra toy in every box for the first year when we checked. Dogs that shred plush toys can switch to Super Chewer, and there are also Combo and Treats Only plans. The FAQ covers allergies, toy preferences, what happens if a dog destroys a toy, and how to skip a month or cancel. BARK says the brand is trusted by 8+ million dogs. The limits are obvious: it only suits dog owners, and the heavier-duty plans cost more than the Classic. For a dog owner who wants a steady supply of new toys and treats, its price and the included shipping are easy to compare with buying the same items in a store.

    What it does well

    • +Free shipping is included from $24 a month
    • +Super Chewer plan for dogs that destroy plush toys
    • +Allergy and toy preference options are covered in the FAQ

    Where it falls short

    • −Only useful for dog owners
    • −Super Chewer and Combo boxes cost more than the Classic
    • −Contents are a surprise within the monthly theme
    Starting price
    From $24 a month
    Shipping
    Free
    Classic box
    2 plush toys and 2 bags of treats
    Dogs served
    8+ million, per the company
    Plans
    Classic, Super Chewer, Combo, Treats Only

    Visit barkbox.com|Read the full BarkBox profile

  5. No. 5

    Birchbox

    A customizable beauty box with a monthly 6-product option and an every-other-month box of full-size products.

    8.3of 10

    Best for beauty shoppers who want to customize every box

    Quality
    7.8
    Experience
    8.6
    Value
    8.6

    Price

    Monthly box from $22; Signature box from $44 every other month

    Quoted from the Birchbox pricing page on November 13, 2026: Starting At $22 /Per Box

    Birchbox offers two customizable beauty boxes. Birchbox Monthly sends 6 products every month, with 1 full-size item included, from $22 a box and up to a $75 value by Birchbox's count. Birchbox Signature sends 4 full-size products every other month from $44 a box, up to a $175 value. Members can customize every box on both plans and buy more from the Members Market. Compared with IPSY, the Monthly box costs $7 more than IPSY Original but guarantees one full-size product, and the ability to customize each box helps shoppers who already know what they like. The site is thinner on detail than its rivals, and the Signature box only ships six times a year. For a beauty buyer who wants to control what arrives without paying for a quarterly box like FabFitFun, Birchbox is a fair middle option.

    What it does well

    • +Every box can be customized
    • +Monthly box includes at least 1 full-size product
    • +Signature plan sends 4 full-size products

    Where it falls short

    • −Monthly box costs $7 more than IPSY Original
    • −Signature ships every other month, not monthly
    • −Beauty only
    Starting price
    $22 a box
    Monthly box
    6 products, 1 full size
    Signature box
    4 full-size products from $44
    Signature frequency
    Every other month
    Customization
    Every box

    Visit birchbox.com|Read the full Birchbox profile

  6. No. 6

    Book of the Month

    A monthly book club that picks 5 to 7 new books each month; members choose one or skip.

    8.3of 10

    Best for fiction readers who want one new book a month

    Quality
    8.2
    Experience
    9.0
    Value
    8.0

    Price

    First book $9.99; gift memberships from $59.99 for 3 books

    Quoted from the Book of the Month pricing page on November 13, 2026: 3-book membership $59.99

    Book of the Month suits readers who want one new hardcover-style pick a month without browsing a whole store. Each month the BOTM editorial team picks 5 to 7 new books, mostly fiction, and members choose one or skip; a skipped month is not charged. New members get their first book for $9.99, and gift memberships cost $59.99 for 3 books, $99.99 for 6 and $199.99 for 12, which works out to about $20 to $16.67 a book. A loyalty program adds savings after three boxes, and the Reader's Guarantee replaces a book you do not like for free. The weak spots are that the regular monthly member price is not printed on the public pages we checked and that the selection leans heavily on new fiction. For readers who would buy a new novel each month anyway, the free skip and guarantee keep the risk low.

    What it does well

    • +Skipping a month costs nothing
    • +First book costs $9.99 for new members
    • +Free replacement under the Reader's Guarantee

    Where it falls short

    • −Fiction focus; the shortlist is mostly new fiction
    • −Regular monthly member price is not shown on the public pages
    • −One book per box
    Intro offer
    First book $9.99
    Gift memberships
    3 books $59.99, 6 books $99.99, 12 books $199.99
    Monthly picks
    5 to 7 new books
    Skipping
    Free, no charge
    Guarantee
    Reader's Guarantee replacement

    Visit bookofthemonth.com|Read the full Book of the Month profile

  7. No. 7

    Stitch Fix

    A personal styling service that ships a box of clothes picked by a stylist, with no subscription required.

    8.3of 10

    Best for people who want clothes picked for them

    Quality
    8.6
    Experience
    8.4
    Value
    8.0

    Price

    $20 styling fee per Fix, credited to items you keep

    Quoted from the Stitch Fix pricing page on November 13, 2026: You’ll pay a $20 styling fee per Fix order, which is then credited to whatever you keep.

    Stitch Fix works differently from the other boxes here: you pay a $20 styling fee per Fix, a stylist picks clothes for your size, style and budget, and you only buy what you keep. The fee is credited to anything you keep, and shipping, returns and exchanges are free. There is no subscription requirement; you can set automatic Fixes or order a box on demand. Stitch Fix says women's and men's items start at around $28 and run up to about $500, and kids' items cover sizes 2T to 18. Sample Fixes on the home page list budgets such as $50 to $150 for elevated basics. The catch is that the box itself is not the product: the clothes cost extra, and if you return everything you still pay the $20 fee. For someone who hates shopping for clothes, it removes the most work of any box we compared.

    What it does well

    • +The styling fee goes toward items you keep
    • +Free shipping and returns
    • +You set your own budget in the style quiz

    Where it falls short

    • −Clothing costs extra on top of the box
    • −Pay for the styling fee even if you return everything
    • −Item prices run up to about $500
    Styling fee
    $20 per Fix, credited to purchases
    Subscription
    Not required
    Item prices
    About $28 to $500 for adults
    Kids' sizes
    2T to 18
    Shipping and returns
    Free

    Visit stitchfix.com|Read the full Stitch Fix profile

  8. No. 8

    Bokksu

    A Japanese snack subscription box with monthly, 3, 6 and 12-month plans.

    8.2of 10

    Best for fans of Japanese snacks and tea

    Quality
    8.4
    Experience
    8.6
    Value
    7.8

    Price

    $39.99 a month month-to-month; $32.99 a month on a 12-month plan

    Quoted from the Bokksu pricing page on November 13, 2026: 12 Months Best Value Save $84 $32.99/mo

    Bokksu ships a box of Japanese snacks, and its pricing page is among the clearest on this list. The 1-month plan costs $39.99 a month, the 3-month plan $35.99, the 6-month plan $33.99 billed every 6 months, and the 12-month plan $32.99 a month, which Bokksu says saves $84. In November, 6 and 12-month plans came with a free handcrafted plate set from the Mino region, and members could add an artisan coffee pairing to a box for $10. Gift wrapping costs $15 and a washi gift box $20. The downside is cost: even the 12-month price is well above Universal Yums at $19, and shipping is added at checkout. For someone who specifically wants Japanese snacks, or a gift for a fan of Japanese food, Bokksu is the focused choice; for a general snack box, Universal Yums costs less.

    What it does well

    • +Clear published price for every plan length
    • +Longer plans cut the monthly price by $7
    • +Gift wrapping and personalized cards available

    Where it falls short

    • −Month-to-month price of $39.99 is the highest monthly price among the food boxes here
    • −Shipping is calculated at checkout
    • −Lowest price needs a 12-month plan
    Month-to-month
    $39.99 a month
    12-month plan
    $32.99 a month
    6-month plan
    $33.99 a month, billed every 6 months
    3-month plan
    $35.99 a month
    Shipping
    Calculated at checkout

    Visit bokksu.com|Read the full Bokksu profile

  9. No. 9

    Alltrue

    The seasonal box formerly called Causebox, with full-size ethical and eco-friendly products every three months.

    8.1of 10

    Best for shoppers who want sustainable products

    Quality
    8.4
    Experience
    7.8
    Value
    8.0

    Price

    $84.95 per seasonal box with free shipping in the contiguous US

    Quoted from the Alltrue pricing page on November 13, 2026: Up to $250+ for only $84.95.

    Alltrue is the box that used to be sold as Causebox; causebox.com now redirects to alltrue.com. Every three months, members get a box of full-size, socially conscious products, which Alltrue values at up to $250+ for $84.95, and shipping is free in the contiguous US. Members can customize the box and buy from an Essentials shop that stocks eco-conscious basics such as toothpaste and toilet paper, plus an add-on market. Alltrue says it has partnered with brands since 2015 on more sustainable packaging. The price is the highest per box on this list, and like FabFitFun it ships four times a year rather than monthly. Its impact and materials claims come from the company itself. For shoppers who want a box built around ethical brands rather than the biggest names, it is the only option here with that focus.

    What it does well

    • +Focus on ethical and eco-friendly brands
    • +Customizable box
    • +Free shipping in the contiguous US

    Where it falls short

    • −Ships every 3 months, not monthly
    • −$84.95 is the highest box price on this list
    • −Product standards are self-reported by the company
    Price
    $84.95 a box
    Frequency
    Every 3 months
    Stated value
    Up to $250+
    Shipping
    Free in the contiguous US
    Former name
    Causebox

    Visit alltrue.com|Read the full Alltrue profile

  10. No. 10

    Loot Crate

    A monthly pop culture box of collectibles, apparel and gear, with Wizarding World and Loot Tees lines.

    7.5of 10

    Best for pop culture and collectibles fans

    Quality
    7.4
    Experience
    8.0
    Value
    7.2

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    No US price was listed when we checked. See the Loot Crate pricing page.

    Loot Crate sends a monthly surprise bundle of collectibles and gear from movie, TV and game franchises. Alongside the main crate it runs a Wizarding World crate with officially licensed items, Loot Tees for apparel, and Loot Fright for horror fans, which was sold out when we checked. Prices are per crate plus shipping, and the site ships to a long list of countries including the United States, Canada, the UK and Australia. Our check showed prices in a non-US currency, so we have marked its USD price as pending rather than guess. The weakness is predictability: you do not know what is in a crate before it arrives, and shipping is charged on top. For fans who enjoy the surprise and want licensed items, it is still the main pop culture box sold today, but shoppers who want to choose their items will do better with FabFitFun or Birchbox.

    What it does well

    • +Licensed pop culture items
    • +Several themed lines
    • +Wide international shipping list

    Where it falls short

    • −Contents are a surprise
    • −Shipping is added on top of the crate price
    • −We could not confirm a USD price from our location
    Frequency
    Monthly
    Lines
    Loot Crate, Loot Fright, Loot Tees, Wizarding World
    Shipping
    Charged per crate
    Contents
    Surprise collectibles, apparel and gear
    Price
    USD check pending

    Visit lootcrate.com|Read the full Loot Crate profile

Before you pick a product or a plan

Check whether it is monthly or seasonal

Not every subscription box ships monthly. IPSY, Universal Yums, BarkBox, Bokksu and Birchbox Monthly ship every month, while FabFitFun and Alltrue send one box every three months and Birchbox Signature ships every other month. Divide a seasonal price by three to compare it with a monthly box: FabFitFun's $64.99 Annual box works out to about $21.66 a month.

Add shipping to the price

Universal Yums and BarkBox include free US shipping, and Alltrue ships free in the contiguous US. IPSY adds shipping on top of its $15 price, Bokksu calculates shipping at checkout, and Loot Crate charges shipping per crate.

Look at the commitment behind the lowest price

Many starting prices need a longer plan. FabFitFun costs $64.99 a box on the Annual plan against $79.99 on the Seasonal plan, and Bokksu costs $32.99 a month on 12 months against $39.99 month to month. Check the renewal terms before you pick the cheapest plan.

Decide how much choice you want

FabFitFun lets members choose all 6 products in each box, and Birchbox lets members customize every box. IPSY tailors boxes to a profile, Book of the Month lets you pick one book from 5 to 7 options, and BarkBox and Loot Crate send a surprise within a theme.

Know what the box price covers

With most boxes the price buys the products in the box. Stitch Fix is different: the $20 styling fee is credited to anything you keep, but the clothes themselves cost extra, with adult items from about $28 to about $500.

Questions readers ask

What is the best subscription box?
IPSY is the best subscription box for most shoppers in 2026. IPSY Original sends 5 deluxe beauty samples every month for $15 plus shipping, the lowest monthly price we found. Universal Yums is the best non-beauty pick at $19 a box with free US shipping.
What is the cheapest subscription box?
IPSY Original is the cheapest box we compared at $15 a month plus shipping. Universal Yums costs $19 a box with free US shipping included, and Birchbox starts at $22 a box.
Is FabFitFun worth it?
FabFitFun is worth it if you want full-size products and are happy with a box every three months. The Annual plan costs $64.99 a box for 6 products you choose, and FabFitFun says its seasonal boxes are valued at up to $350.
What is the best subscription box for dogs?
BarkBox is the best subscription box for dogs on this list. Its Classic box sends 2 plush toys and 2 bags of treats from $24 a month with free shipping, and a Super Chewer plan covers tough chewers.
What is the best subscription box for a gift?
Universal Yums is a strong gift pick because every box size includes free US shipping and a country booklet, from $19. Book of the Month gift memberships start at $59.99 for 3 books, and IPSY, BarkBox and Bokksu also sell gift subscriptions.
Can you skip or cancel a subscription box?
Yes, most of these boxes let you skip or cancel. Book of the Month does not charge for a skipped month, Stitch Fix needs no subscription at all, and BarkBox covers skipping and cancelling in its FAQ.
What happened to Causebox?
Causebox is now called Alltrue, and causebox.com redirects to alltrue.com. Alltrue sends a seasonal box of ethical, full-size products every three months for $84.95.

Spotted an error or a price change? Write to editorial@comredix.com

How we work is in our editorial policy. Makers change prices, plans and terms often, so check the price on their site before you buy or upgrade.

More rankings