OLLY Sleep Gummies review

OLLY Sleep is the gummy on this list, and for many buyers the format is the point. The Blackberry Zen gummies blend melatonin with L-theanine and extracts of chamomile, passionflower and lemon balm, and OLLY says they are NSF Certified, meaning independently tested for quality, safety and label claims. The jar of 25 servings costs $13.99, about $0.56 a night; a 35-serving jar costs $17.99 and the 60-serving pouch $30.99, about $0.52 a night. Subscribers save 15%, and shipping is free over $59. The product page has 1,237 reviews with a 4.2 average. We could not read the melatonin amount per serving in the page text we checked, so look at the supplement facts panel before buying if dose matters to you. OLLY also notes the gummies are not intended to treat insomnia and may cause drowsiness. Gummies cost more per night than tablets, which keeps OLLY in the lower half of this ranking.

Who it is for

people who prefer a gummy

Price

$13.99 for 25 servings; pouches of 30 and 60 servings also sold.

25 Servings $13.99
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 14, 2026.

Key features

• Blend of melatonin, L-theanine and chamomile, passionflower and lemon balm extracts
• NSF Certified, per the product page
• Blackberry Zen flavor with a hint of mint
• Sizes: 25 servings, 35 servings, 30 and 60 serving pouches
• Subscribe and save 15%

Strengths and weaknesses

• Strength: The only gummy on this list
• Strength: NSF Certified for quality and label claims
• Strength: 1,237 reviews on the page with a 4.2 average
• Weakness: About $0.56 a night, eight times Nature Made
• Weakness: The melatonin amount was not shown in the page text we checked
• Weakness: Free shipping only on orders over $59

Key facts

• Main ingredients: Melatonin, L-theanine, botanical extracts
• Format: Gummy
• Certification: NSF Certified
• Sizes: 25, 35, 30 pouch, 60 pouch
• Price per night: About $0.56 (25 servings)

Where it ranks

OLLY Sleep Gummies is No. 7 in our Best Sleep Supplements verdict.